Thursday, December 11, 2008

The Best Friend 2



Book Description:

Becka is so relieved. She's finally ready to forget all the horrible things her "best friend" Honey did to her real friends. She can even forget the way SHE was blamed for it all. She's completely over it. So why does she keep seeing Honey everywhere she goes? At first she thinks it's her imagination. But then the threats begin. The phone calls late at night. The terrifying messages left in her locker. Honey is back. And this time she won't stop until Becka is dead.

Letter To The Reader:

A few years ago, I wrote a book called The Best Friend. And hundreds of you wrote to tell me how unhappy you were with the ending. You thought Honey Perkins should pay for her crimes.

But I needed your help. I wasn't sure exactly what should happen to Honey. So we held a contest to let you decide. I got thousands of great ideas. It was hard to choose, but I finally picked my favorite. A girl named Sara Bikman from Grafton, Wisconsin, sent in the winning entry. Thanks, Sara!

So here is the book you've all been waiting for. Honey is back--and she's after Becka Norwood. But this time, Honey will get what she deserves. Won't she?

R.L. Stine

My Description:

* Sara Bikman, for the love of all things good in this world, do not disappoint me. *

Part One

It's the first day of school and Becka is feeling pretty nervous. After all, she's new. Yes, after the events of the last book, Becka was so traumatized that her parents moved to nearby Waynesbridge. You're joking, right, Sara Bikman? I mean, come on. Everyone knows that Waynesbridge sucks! No murdering psychos, no Fear family curses, no raspy-voiced crank callers. It's just boring...it isn't Shadyside! And I never thought I would say this, but I miss Shadyside already. *sigh* Becka goes to the guidance counselor's office and is asked to talk once more about Honey. Becka basically rehashes everything from the first book which I find incredibly pointless especially since the counselor, Miss Englund, completely dismisses it. Becka steps out into the hall and spots three boys rounding the corner. She freaks out because one of them looks exactly like Bill Planter. Now we all know old Planter is dead and gone, but Becka goes running up to the poor unsuspecting boy anyway: "Bill! Bill!" She throws her tentacles around him and sobs into his shoulder a bit before finally realizing that it isn't Bill at all. The boy is totally embarrassed and his friends are laughing their asses off at this spectacle. Becka just lies on the floor and cries some more while the boys tell her that the guy's name is Steve. Ok, go away now. Becka finally gets her shit together and Steve is nice enough to show her where her first class is. She has a man named Mr. Wright for history and you can already tell he's going to be an asshole. Becka enters the room and Mr. Wright has already begun teaching. She apologizes for being late and he snottily tells her "You're about three weeks late." because she just moved here. Becka takes a seat and a red-haired girl named Glynis Quinn introduces herself and tells Becka to take good notes because this course apparently kicks everyone's ass. Glynis says that Wright only lectures, he never asks questions or even acknowledges the class. I find that highly unlikely in a high school course. After a while, the bell rings and as Becka glances down at her notebook, she realizes in horror that she didn't take notes at all. She simply scribbled the word 'BILL' over and over again. Stop yanking my chain, Sara Bikman.

At the end of the day, Becka is standing at her locker when Glynis comes up. They chat a little before being interrupted by some grungy guy named Frankie. Becka thinks he's pretty cute with his silvery eyes and grubby flannel shirt. To each his own. Or HER own. Turns out Becka has biology with Frankie and he asks her if she likes to cut stuff up. What a winner. After he and Glynis get all lovey dovey (VOMIT!) Becka realizes that they're together so she may as well stop looking at Frankie likes he's a delicious T-bone. He invites Becka to come with him and Glynis for Cokes and pizza which convinces Becka that he's into her even though he already has Glynis. I don't remember Becka being so pathetic in the first book. They walk a few blocks to a place called Pizzaz (Waynesbridge's version of Pete's Pizza) and take their seats. Becka freaks out for the 36474 time when she spots Eric (that dude she briefly dated in the first book) enter. I don't get what her deal is. Seriously. She never really liked Eric all that much, but her head is about to explode from the happiness she's feeling at seeing him. She runs up and hugs him and asks if he wants to join them. He declines and says he was just driving around. Then why the hell did he come inside? And what's he doing over in Waynesbridge? Oh well. She asks to come with him and he agrees. As soon as they get inside his car, she grabs him and kisses him HARD. I'm beginning to think Sara Bikman didn't even read the first book. He asks her out for Saturday night, she says yes, and then she gets out of the car and walks home. Why? Wasn't he going to drive her? Ok, whatever. No more questions! Maybe. When she gets home, Becka starts exhibiting shades of Honey's behavior. Uh-oh. She thinks about the shade of nail polish that Glynis wears and how Glynis styles her hair and decides that she will start painting her nails with that polish and straightening her hair to look like Glynis's. She doesn't really wanna be like Glynis, though. She just thinks that it will attract Frankie. Poor little creep.

After school the next day, Becka rushes to the mall to buy the nail polish. At home, after she finishes painting her chewed fingernails, Frankie calls. Their conversation is so awkward and lame that it makes me cringe. The gist of it is that Frankie has noticed Becka no-so-subtly staring at him and he just wants her to know that he feels the same way. "I just felt something, I guess. Like a flash." I'm feeling a flash, too. A flash of total sadness at how poorly this book is playing out. Then again, what did I really expect? ANYWAY! What happens next irritates the crap out of me: "And then I realized I was fantasizing the entire conversation." NO! Is this really where this book is going? Becka believes she's going crazy just like Honey which leads into a flashback to the night of Trish's Christmas party when Honey pushed Trish down the stairs. She snaps out of it and turns her attention back to her nails. She walks over to the mirror to check them out and flips out when she sees what she's done. She somehow wrote the word 'BILL' all over her freaking face with nail polish. Please. No more of this. I...just...can't!

It is now Thursday afternoon and Becka is stuck in Miss Englund's office. She isn't too worried about what Englund has to say--it's 4:00 and she's supposed to be meeting Glynis. So Becka tells Miss Englund everything she wants to hear: "Mainly, I've been feeling really happy. I don't imagine that I see Bill everywhere I go. And I hardly think about Honey at all. It's like I'm heading in the right direction now." Lies! All lies! Eventually Becka makes her way to Glynis's mansion. In a scene ripped straight from the first book, Becka tries on some of Glynis's clothes. Glynis's mother comes into the room, laughs, and tells the girls that they look so much alike which upsets Becka for some reason: "What's funny about it? We're friends, aren't we?" Glynis goes downstairs with her mom to help her hang a poster (that seems like a one person job) and while she's gone, Becka helps herself to a shirt and sweater from Glynis's closet, shoving them into her backpack.

On Friday night, Becka goes shopping with Frankie and Glynis. On the way to Division Street Mall, Glynis asks Becka if she borrowed some of her things and Becka is quite honest about it: "Yes. Do you need them back right away?" Glynis says no and Becka tells her "I'm going out tomorrow night with a guy I know. I thought maybe I'd wear your stuff. But it's way too warm." Anyone who thinks Becka deserves a bitch slap, raise your hand. They finally reach the mall and Becka gets nervous because she's afraid of seeing someone she knows. They're afraid, too, trust me. At a store called The Clothes Hangar, Becka is startled to find Eric. He works there on Friday and Saturday in the stock room and says he gets paid really well. I need a moment to laugh my ass off. *a moment* Ok, I'm good. It's just that Eric acts as if he's a fucking millionaire or something. Anyway, Frankie and Glynis come over and Becka introduces them before they run off to the food court. What happens next is a total WTF moment. Eric says "Why did they call you Becka? You heard me, Honey. Those two kids--why did they call you Becka? Did you tell them your name was Becka? Honey, are you pretending to be Becka? What's going on?" This can't be happening. I don't know whether to cry or vomit or both. I really truly hate this book. The worst part is, it really IS Honey pretending to be Becka. Honey freaks out, screaming "I'm Becka!" while trying to choke Eric, but she freezes when he tells her that she can't be Becka because the REAL Becka is right behind her. Swing low sweet chariot...come and take me home. Honey completely freaks out further, grabs a long string of beads off a rack, and begins choking Eric with them. What the hell did HE do?! His face turns purple and blood drips down his neck where some of the beads broke and cut into his skin. Becka only pulls Honey off him AFTER he's dead. Good work, moron. Honey is still insane with rage and throws the bloody beads at Becka while screaming "You killed Eric, Becka! And I'll pay you back! You murdered Bill and now you've murdered my new life!" Employees of the store FINALLY take notice (is everyone here completely braindead?) and come running. Honey runs to the entrance and points at Becka who is stupidly standing over Eric's body holding the bloody beads and says "She killed him! Stop her!" As soon as Becka saw Honey in the store, she should've gotten the hell out of there so whatever happens next, she deserves it. Of course I don't find out because...

Part Two

Thanks for the cliffhanger, Sara "Stine" Bikman. NOT. I'm so pissed off at this book that I really don't care what happens now. I think the story is now being told from the REAL Becka's point of view. It's Monday afternoon, the day of Eric's funeral. Trish, Lilah, and Becka are sitting in a church pew crying over Eric which I find strange because none of these girls really gave a damn about him. Maybe that's why they're crying? Becka is more upset over the fact that Honey has once again wormed her way into Becka's life. Apparently Honey ran away from the mental institution where she was being housed (where was she living? That's never explained.), enrolled at Waynesbridge High using Becka's name, and forged transcripts and such. Wouldn't the school have required her parents to do the registering? This crap is so full of plot holes, I don't even wanna think about it. The girls rise and start walking toward the front of the church when suddenly Becka turns and spots Honey standing in the doorway. This chick has nerves of steel, man. Oh wait. It was just Becka's overactive imagination. Damn this book. They finally leave the church and HOLY SHIT--Bill Planter is alive! He comes running up to the girls and chats for a bit, but Becka wants nothing to do with him. She's over their relationship and is now dating a guy named Larry. Bill finally takes the hint and gets lost. BOOOO! I miss Planter! *sob* Becka tells Trish and Lilah that she can't be with Bill because it brings up too many bad memories. How the hell do you think he feels? He was the one who was stabbed! Becka gets home and goes to her room. The phone rings, but don't worry--it's a just a heavy breather. I welcome this after all those raspy-voiced fuckers that seem to plague these books.

Becka has an afterschool job because her doctor recommended she do something besides sitting around crying and moping and generally getting on everyone's nerves. She works at--get this--The Hackers Cafe. *sigh* Tuesday afternoon, Larry comes to visit while she's at work. Larry is a goofy, red-haired, Bugs Bunny look-a-like. No, I'm serious. Becka actually compares this poor soul to Bugs because his two front teeth stick out a little. Becka acts like a total bitch to him because he has no money and can't order anything. As he leaves, she tells him she'll call him later. Don't bother! Becka's shift ends at 7:30 and it's already getting dark outside. As she's walking to her car, she hears someone behind her. It's just my man Bill. He desperately wants to talk to her for a second and she finally agrees. He basically reiterates that he wants to be with her and ends up grabbing her arm. She freaks out and tells him to get away, but he won't until she agrees to be with him again. Bill, you're becoming difficult to like. Don't give up your title as The Only Likeable Person In This Piece Of Shit Book! The amazing Larry comes running up out of nowhere and shoves Bill. Bill takes off like a wimp (you totally could've beaten his ass, Bill!) and Becka unlocks her car. She screams her head off when she sees the damage that has been done. Someone cut the seats to shreds and laid a dismembered rat on the front seat. Yum. Becka repeatedly screams "Honey!" and Larry manages to get her inside the car (after disposing of the rat carcass I pray?) . He drives off and Becka can't help but think how an angry Larry looks nothing like Bugs Bunny. *sigh* Once home, Becka jumps into bed and takes some sedatives. After a bit, she calms down and starts thinking about what Larry must think of her now. He probably didn't think much of you to begin with if that makes you feel any better. Becka decides that she has to know if Honey is now living next door again. As she prepares to go over and take a look, the phone rings. Of course it does. It's Trish who is calling to report that Bill was just at her house and he's a total mess. He told Trish that Becka's rejections hurt more than being stabbed. Becka just repeats what she said earlier about him bringing back too many memories. That's an excuse! That house he was stabbed in is right next door to Becka yet she says nothing about that place bringing back bad memories. Go to hell, Becka. She ends up hanging up on Trish because Trish feels really bad for Bill and Becka doesn't like that. What a bitch! The phone rings again a few minutes later, but this time it's some RASPY-VOICED weirdo: "You killed Bill!" Say it ain't so!

I guess Becka is choosing to ignore the psycho caller because she simply heads on over to Honey's house instead of checking to see if something really HAS happened to Bill. She sees a light in one of the windows and creeps over to it in the hopes that she'll be able to see inside. She trips over a bag of fertilizer, but doesn't break her ankle or anything good like that. She catches herself before she falls and manages to peek inside the window. It's just Honey's dad who has fallen asleep in front of the TV in his armchair with his beer can in hand. Becka slips away from the window and is about to drag her sorry ass up to another one when someone grabs her from behind. It's Lilah. WTF? She says she came over to Becka's house because she needed to show her something, but she saw her creeping around over here and decided to see what was going on. Before Becka can answer, Honey's dad opens the door and asks who's out there. He gets a little crazy when he spots Becka. He doesn't want her anywhere near him because of the trouble she's caused and he thinks she knows where Honey is but isn't telling. He finally goes back inside and the girls go back to Becka's house. Lilah tells Becka that the man over there isn't really Honey's father. She shows Becka an article that apparently proves this fact. The article is about this girl named Hannah who witnessed her father shoot her mother, her twin brother, and then himself. Becka and Lilah knew Hannah and her twin brother; the murders occurred when they were in 4th grade. Hannah was a nerd who was big and clumsy and no-one liked her. Becka and some of her shitty little friends told Hannah that they wanted her to join their club. She was excited about the prospect of having friends and decided to go through with the initiation which consisted of her climbing onstage during a school assembly, getting on all fours, and barking like a dog. Poor Hannah. Of course the entire thing was a joke to embarrass Hannah in front of the whole school. As Becka remembers all this, she's ashamed. Not ashamed enough! Of course Hannah is Honey. OF COURSE. So no wonder she wants to kill Becka. The phone rings yet again and it's another weirdo: "It's me. I'm coming to see you, Becka. I have something for you. Something shiny and sharp." Yay!

Part Three

The next day, Becka pays a visit to her therapist, Dr. Perlberg. She tells him all about the recent events involving Honey and asks him for more pills cause she needs a fix, dammit! He writes her a prescription and she leaves. That's it? He didn't even give her his thoughts on the whole Honey thing. How worthless of him. She walks out to her car and freezes when she hears someone coughing. It seemed like the noise came from behind her car. She calls out "Honey" and Honey comes bounding out roaring like maniac. She chases Becka across the parking lot and tackles her. She sits on top of Becka and punches her for a bit. Then she grabs her head and begins to twist. Becka pleads with Honey to stop and says she knows that Honey is really Hannah and she's so sorry for all the things she did to her in the past. Honey responds by screaming "I'm Becka!" and slamming the real Becka's head into the asphalt. Ouch. She keeps ramming Becka's head into the ground until Becka is knocked unconscious. She wakes up later, alone and in a lot of pain. She retrieves her keys and manages to drive herself home. Later, she calls Trish to report the news. Her mom took her to the emergency room and her dad called the police to report the incident. She needed stitches, but she's basically ok. I'm surprised she isn't absolutely catatonic at this point...

On Sunday night, Larry picks her up in his dad's Range Rover and they head for the theater. Becka's paranoia kills the mood, though. She's terrified that Honey will be lurking around, following them all night, waiting to kill them both. Why the hell would she kill him? It's YOU she wants! After the movie, a girl accidentally pokes Becka with an umbrella and Becka basically brings the place down with her screams because she thought it was Honey and a knife. Shut up, Becka. They go to a diner to have some coffee. Predictably, Becka flips her lid in the first five minutes they're there. She mistakes a waitress for Honey and starts screaming her head off. *sigh* "I'm not okay! She's crazy! She's trying to kill me!" That poor waitress sure as hell didn't sign on for this crap. Larry drags Becka out and drives her home. Her parents aren't home and she refuses to allow Larry to stick around so I think we all know what's going to happen here. She goes upstairs and climbs into bed without turning on the light. She immediately feels something gross and squishy all over her back. She flips on the light and sees that her sheets have been slashed and soaked in blood. Sick. Written on the mirror in blood are the words "This Is U" Uh, ok? Her parents enter the room then just as Becka completely loses it. They fill her with pills, but it doesn't help much. The next day, she stays home from school and sleeps the day away. Trish and Lilah come over in the evening to give her the assignments of the day. She also receives another call: "It was so easy to get into your house. Wait for me, Becka. Your best friend is coming over tonight. Tonight's the night, Becka. Wait for your best friend." Oooo. Becka runs downstairs (she's alone; I have no clue where the parents are), opens the door, and finds Bill standing on the other side. She frantically explains that they have to leave NOW and Bill says they can go to his uncle's cabin in the Fear Street woods. You're starting to smell fishy, Bill. The phone rings AGAIN and Becka answers, but it's just Lilah and Becka hangs up on her. Nice. Bill and Becka jump into his car, but they're blocked from getting out of the driveway by another car. It isn't Honey; just some people turning around. Yawn.

They make it to the cabin. Bill tells Becka to make herself comfortable while he goes out to fetch some firewood. As soon as he exits, the phone rings. I'm getting extremely sick of the phone calls. It's Lilah. How would she know the number for this place? Why do I expect any logical explanation? And furthermore, where am I? Lilah tells Becka that Honey was arrested; they caught her upstate two days ago. Lilah says they must have caught her the day after she kicked Becka's ass in the parking lot. How could she have gotten that far away so quickly? Becka freaks out because now she has no idea who broke into her house and smeared blood all over her room and made those threatening phone calls. Bill creeps up behind Becka and tells her to put the phone down. Oh Bill. Come on, man. NO! Why does it have to be you? Why does Sara Bikman hate men? That's another poorly written story for another day I suppose. He rips the phone out of the wall and hurls it across the room. She asks him why he's doing this and why he called her. He tells her he didn't call her at all. So who did? Trish comes inside then and confesses. Dammit! The two characters I liked the most! Well, now I guess I like them more... Trish is pissed off at Becka because Becka wasn't there for her when she was in the hospital after Honey pushed her down the stairs. She says that Becka has hurt both she AND Bill and they're sick of it. Trish brings out a knife and in another scene ripped out of the first book, Bill is confused and says this wasn't part of the plan. She stabs Bill right in the chest for his insolence and says to Becka "Look what you did, Becka! You stabbed him again!" Ok, I think Sara has no idea how to end this crap because now she's just robbing scene after scene from the first book. Just as Trish is preparing to cut Becka's throat, sirens begin wailing in the distance. Becka figures that Lilah called the cops. Somehow Becka gets the knife and cuts Trish's neck a little. Trish cowers into the corner while Becka crawls over to Bill who is miraculously still alive. The last line of the book? "I'll be a good friend. I promise."

Conclusion? Kill me.

Next time: "Cat" A story of a dead feline's revenge. Can't be any worse than this crap...

37 comments:

  1. ...The Hell is this? Although I thought the first part of the book was great in concept. It seems to have not paid much heed to the end of the first book, though.

    ReplyDelete
  2. What a disappointment! I loved the first Best Friend book. I was really expecting more. Can't believe this was the winner out of thousands of entries.

    Thanks for the recap, though! I didn't even know there was a Best Friend 2 book, and since I liked the first one so much, I really wanted to find out about it.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Yeah, if this was the winner, I'd hate to see the losers.

    But I sort of get the feeling that Sara Bikman probably just suggested one of the plot points (like, "Becka enrolls in a new school in Waynesbridge but it turns she's really Honey") and the rest of the book was made up by Stine...or a ghostwriter.

    But I'm glad after hearing so much about it that a book is finally set in Waynesbridge. It's better than a random ski cabin or resort of some sort. And I figure that since Waynesbridge is so close, it'd probably have some Fear spillover.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Yeah, this book totally sucked. I don't really know what I expected, though. The ones that Stine actually wrote weren't that good so why would a fledgling writer's story be any better? Bah, no more BEST FRIEND!

    ReplyDelete
  5. So, uh, how exactly did Honey pay?

    ReplyDelete
  6. Honey got arrested. That was pretty much all that was said about it. I wish there were more Honey action here! Maybe that would've saved this abomination...

    ReplyDelete
  7. i wonder if sara bikman is ashamed of herself?

    ReplyDelete
  8. If she isn't, she should be!

    I'm extremely curious as to what the other entries in this little contest were like.

    ReplyDelete
  9. The real question in all of this is whatever happened to Sara Bikman from Grafton, Wisconsin? Do you think she googles her name and will one day stumble across this? Also, did the book say what she won?

    ReplyDelete
  10. She won R.L. Stine turning her plot idea into an actual book. This may have been a booby prize.

    ReplyDelete
  11. wow, this book sounds like it fails pretty hard...it kind of made a dramatic nose swerve away from giving much closure on Honey huh.
    But I think I might love it a little bit for the scene where she writes Bill all over her face in nail polish, that is hilariously demented, and I don't think I'm going to be able to shake that mental image for a while.

    ReplyDelete
  12. Natalie, I suppose Sara's only prize was the publication of her story. I have to agree with Anonymous--BOOBY!

    Babysitter, the entire book was hilariously demented :p

    ReplyDelete
  13. I can't wait for the Cat book. That sounds vaguely like a Goosebumps book...

    ReplyDelete
  14. Anon, I think the book you're thinking of is "Cry of the Cat"...or something like that. I don't know. My Goosebumps are dusty and neglected. All in the name of Fear Street. *sigh* I have no life.

    ReplyDelete
  15. Glynis says that Wright only lectures, he never asks questions or even acknowledges the class. I find that highly unlikely in a high school course.

    I don't. You must have had a decent high school or something, I had a few teachers like this.

    ReplyDelete
  16. I also had some teachers like that. They totally sucked and I had no idea what was going on most of the time. Of course that could have been the fault of all that pot I smoked. Oops!

    ReplyDelete
  17. Deb, wow. Just...WOW. Welcome to the blog. Are you still smoking pot? I should think you'd need it to read these reviews.

    ReplyDelete
  18. I get the feeling that there was no Sara Bikman, and that this was done by a ghostwriter who had only a vague understanding of what happened in the first book. Aside from the inconsistencies already mentioned, in the first book don't they find an old class picture that featured Honey and it jarred their memories about what she was like? How could they overlook/not recall such a horrible prank they pulled, or her actual name? That's why I think it was ghostwritten, an actual fan who read the first book and was upset about how it ended wouldn't have fucked up such a detail if they wanted to tell the story "right."

    (To go on a tangent, that was also one of the things that made the first Best Friend so intriguing--here was this girl from their past that they barely remembered, so they couldn't explain at all why she was suddenly obsessed with them. By giving Honey such an obvious motivation, one that nobody could have missed before, tears away one of the most unique things about that first book.)

    Another thing I wouldn't have expected from a vengeful fan is the fact that Honey plays absolutely no part in the climax of the book.

    ReplyDelete
  19. Good point! I wondered what had happened to that scene from the first book. So, it's a conspiracy. Or Sara Bikman is just a terrible, terrible writer... so R.L. Stine felt an affinity with her. That or they picked names out of a hat?

    I think most of us could have come up with a better plot than this, though.

    ReplyDelete
  20. What complete utter crap. What was Stine thinking when he chose this out of thousands of entries.

    ReplyDelete
  21. Um... wow... this IS Sara Bikman...

    I wrote into this contest when I was 13... almost 15 years ago. I wrote in about "the twins" getting harassed at school & Honey turning into a psycho. The whole getting up in front of a crowd & barking like a dog... that was my "plot". & that was about it :)

    What would you have liked to have happened? I'd love to hear it... whoever has the best "alternative ending", I'll blog it. Let's have some fun. Let me know at saragraves@live.com and you can read about it at http://iamtheposterchild.blogspot.com/

    ReplyDelete
  22. Geez.....this book gave me such a headache! I was intrigued then confused then outraged! If she was gonna cut Trish's throat, she should've slit it! Honey didn't meet a gruesome end and----ahhhh!!! I'm too frusterated too finish! I read this book before and it was good but now it's just infuriating!

    ReplyDelete
  23. How utterly disappointing. You have no idea how hard I looked for this book in my public library. They didn't have it so I requested that they buy it and when they FINALLY did I was so disappointed I wanted to cry!!! I think I'm just going to ignore that this was ever published. The first one , however , was AMAZING!

    ReplyDelete
  24. can't believe sara "stine" bikman actually commented on this. now that's epic.

    Speaking of epics, Best Friend 2 was an epic fail. The first book had an awesome ending, really. Call me sadistic but I always enjoyed the endings so much more when they weren't happy/lame joke/pete's pizza

    ReplyDelete
  25. I'm really dissappointed, I have been wanting to read this book for years and I get this? I've seen fanfucks cooler than this...this novel should have never seen the light of day.

    ReplyDelete
  26. When I got in the first book to the last chapter I was so frustrated because of the twist ending (I really hate twist endings, trust me on that). I was 9 at that time so I was really little girl, but that book got me. Just a few weeks ago I found out there is book 2. I was so happy! I wanted to know what happened with Becky, Bill and Honey.I hated that we didn't know anythin about Honey - from where did she come, why she did come back, why she stuck on Becky so much or if she is some mental freak xD (bet on that).
    But after this...
    I'm so disappointed! This was supposed to be about Becky and Honey, we should get there more action of Honey and more informations about her - like some creepy story about her lol... but what? U cant call this proper part 2 >.>
    What the hell was that about Bill and Trish? How come he was alive? Didn't had he funeral or what? And what about Trish? How can she say such things like that? Becky was threaten by Honey she was scared to contact Trish because Honey could kill her! Who would kill their best friend because of something like THAT? And Becky was never so bitchy as in this book... how Stine could change her character that much?
    But the start of the book was pretty good. I liked that (I hoped for somethin creepy) and I wont complain about why did it win... it was a good thought for a thirteen year old girl - Honey thinkin she is Becky lol...
    But then everythin was fucked up. Why they didn't explain why Honey is not with Becky anymore??? How they did prove Honey is freak and becky did nothin wrong? And how come when Honey thought she is becky and even moved to another town - how come there was Eric and becky??? didnt they lived somewhere else? And didnt Honey break up Eric already for Bill? And that incident when they were little... wasnt that TOO much? How come the girls didn't remembered somethin that important earlier? And I believe if Honey hated Becky for that why she choosed Becky and not to someone else? Was the revenge just to stole / destroy Becky's life? But then why would she think later she is Becka... someone she hates so much? I think she would rather kill Becky too than being her best friend...

    So well.I think I would write the part two better than Stine - no - I think ANYONE would write it better.But I still wanna buy the book :)

    ReplyDelete
  27. Does anyone else think Honey should have won anyway?!

    ReplyDelete
  28. Seriously???????? I went from book store to book store in search of the this part and I didn't find it. They said it wasn't available in my country! It makes no sense at all!!!! Kill me!!!!!1

    ReplyDelete
  29. Holy shit, I can't believe Sara Bikman found this blog, read your summary and actually commented on it. That's insane!

    The first part of the book was the worst plot twist. It was so obvious that Honey was pretending to be Becka there in the beginning. Because Becka would never act like that.

    What I don't understand is why would Honey go after Becka instead of Trish or Lilah instead. Why did she feel the need to become "best friends" with Becka instead of them. They're just as much responsible for the humiliation she went through as a kid as she is. Not to mention how stupid her reason for exacting revenge on Becka are. I mean yes they humiliated her in front of her peers, but it's elementary school. It's not like everyone would remember that, hell even the girls didn't even remember her until they came across that article. How did they not recognize her before? This sequel sucked, the first one wasn't even half as bad.

    ReplyDelete
  30. For someone who claims to hate these books, you sure read a lot of them.

    ReplyDelete
  31. oky..i saw some people saying Honey had no part in the climax of the book or the ending of the book...i'd like to say"HELLLOOO...the last line is, "I'll be a good friend. I promise"...so obviously its Honey again!!
    N i really hated Trisha getting sooo bad...otherwise it was totally cool...!!

    ReplyDelete
  32. i really dint understand the ending of the first book it drove me nuts!!

    ReplyDelete
  33. Jesus, Bill, will you ever stop getting hurt? poor guy. even if he was the bad guy. and idk who wrote the worse version, sara or stine.

    ReplyDelete
  34. Seriously ???? I went from book store to book stor searching for this stupid book? Come on stine you could have chosen a better entry

    ReplyDelete
  35. Hahahhaa I just HAD to check out Sara Bikman's blog and... It SUCKS!!!! Wow! Not just your plot is lame, but your whole life is.
    As Always great description Fear!!! U Rock!
    -Sam, Mexico

    ReplyDelete
  36. This one is worse than the first book. Maybe I should write a treatment for it and call it something else

    ReplyDelete
  37. Searching for the Best Dating Site? Join to find your perfect date.

    ReplyDelete